Imagine a hockey game where a team claws back from a two-goal deficit, only to snatch victory in overtime with a dramatic one-timer. That's exactly what happened when the San Jose Sharks stunned the Dallas Stars in a thrilling 5–4 comeback win on January 10, 2026. But here's where it gets even more intriguing: this wasn't just any win—it was fueled by Tyler Toffoli’s heroics, who scored twice, including the overtime winner, and added an assist. Controversial question: Is Toffoli the unsung hero of the Sharks’ recent success, or is this just a fleeting moment of brilliance? Let us know in the comments!
The Sharks’ victory wasn’t a solo effort, though. Adam Gaudette chipped in with a goal and an assist, while Alexander Wennberg and Jeff Skinner also found the net. Meanwhile, Macklin Celebrini continued his scorching streak, tallying three assists to extend his point streak to 13 games. And this is the part most people miss: Celebrini now has 46 assists on the season, including two goals and five assists in overtime alone—a stat that underscores his clutch performance. Alex Nedeljkovic stood tall in net, making 16 saves to secure the win.
For the Stars, Jason Robertson led the charge with his 26th goal of the season and an assist, while Mikko Rantanen added a goal and an assist of his own. Justin Hryckowian and Kyle Capobianco also scored, and Casey DeSmith made 26 saves in a valiant effort. Despite their strong start, the Stars couldn’t hold off the Sharks’ late surge.
The game’s turning point came in overtime when Toffoli buried a one-timer off a pass from William Eklund, capping off a remarkable comeback. The Sharks’ power play was lethal, going 4 for 6, with Toffoli scoring twice on the man advantage. In contrast, the Stars went 0 for 2 on the power play, a missed opportunity that may have cost them the game.
Let’s rewind to the key moments: Hryckowian opened the scoring in the first period, and Robertson doubled the lead late in the frame. The Sharks responded in the second period with Wennberg’s power-play goal and Skinner’s equalizer. Capobianco briefly put the Stars back ahead, but Rantanen’s 18th goal of the season in the third period seemed to seal the deal—until Toffoli and Gaudette struck late to force overtime.
Looking ahead, the Stars travel to Los Angeles on Monday, while the Sharks host Vegas on Sunday. With San Jose now riding a three-game winning streak and six wins in their last seven games, the question remains: Can they keep this momentum going? Or will the Stars regroup and bounce back? Bold prediction: This Sharks team might just be a dark horse contender this season. Agree or disagree?
For more NHL action, visit AP NHL.
Copyright 2026 STATS LLC and Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
